Bye-de-bye: a fond farewell to the godfather of British sitcoms

John Walsh looks back at the work of David Croft, co-creator of Dad's Army and 'Allo 'Allo

John Walsh

Prolific writer and commentator John Walsh contributes columns to the paper as well as writing features, interviews and restaurant reviews. He has been editor of The Independent Magazine, literary editor of the Sunday Times and features editor of the London Evening Standard.

More

Articles from John Walsh

From the blogs

The 2011 “Questions to Which the Answer is No” Awards

Here are my favourites in the series of Questions to Which the Answer is No from the past 12 months.

The potential British sports stars of 2012

2012 will see the Olympics come to London and the Euros take place in Poland and Ukraine in what pro...

2011: The year of Barefoot leaders

So often the archetypal leader that one is accustomed to hearing of are the suited and booted CEOs, ...

A fitting end to a disastrous year in Indian politics

It was a fitting end to a disastrous year for corruption-ridden India’s floundering government, dest...

David Croft and his writing partners gave the world immortal phrases: "Don't tell him, Pike!" and "Listen very carefully, I shall say zis only vunce" and "Mister Gunner Lah-di-dah Graham" and "Ah've been having a terrible time with mah pussy," and "You stupid boy!" and "Morning campers!" and "Don't panic!" and a hundred others.

They may not be lines of Shakespearean depth and resonance, but they're firmly embedded in the brains of anyone who watched BBC1 in the 1970s and 1980s.

Without Croft, who has died at the age of 89, we would never have fretted over the condition of Mrs Slocombe's pussy in Are You Being Served?, or learned of the Nazis' plan to steal the priceless painting Fallen Madonna Mit Der Big Boobies in 'Allo 'Allo, or wondered if Sergeant Wilson's indulgence towards Private Pike in Dad's Army might conceal a family secret.

Without Croft, we'd never have had the most unlikely chart-topping song in British pop history, "Whispering Grass" by Don ("Lofty") Estelle and Windsor ("Sergeant-Major") Davies.

In a statement, his family said the "truly great man" had died peacefully in his sleep at his home in Portugal.

Tributes immediately poured in from writers and comedians. Actor Melvyn Hayes, one of the stars of It Ain't Half Hot Mum, described him as "genius" who was "a privilege to work with".

Nostalgia was the key ingredient of almost all Croft's sitcoms: a look back at 1940s or 1950s Britain that was always affectionate. The soldiers in Dad's Army – based on the Home Guard, who were supposed to defend the English coast while the real army was fighting overseas – were too old, too young, too sick or too crooked to have joined up.

Their attempts to follow the orders of the bank manager martinet Captain Mainwaring and the wholesale incompetence displayed by all involved combined humour and pathos in a tradition that derived from Noel Coward and Terence Rattigan.

Much of Croft's work was autobiographical: he served in the Royal Artillery during the war, had run-ins with stroppy ARP wardens (the platoon's sworn enemy in Dad's Army), been entertainments officer in India, and produced stage shows at Butlins holiday camp.

He transformed these experiences into comedies of class. His favourite subject was snobbery and the human urge to look down on others. The snooty ballroom-dancing Stewart-Hargreaves in Hi-de-Hi, the caste-obsessed Rangi Ram in It Ain't Half Hot, Mum, the grotesque Mrs Slocombe in Are You Being Served?, the pretensions of Mainwaring – these are fine additions to the rich tradition of fictional snobs.

David Croft and his writing partners, Jimmy Perry and Jeremy Lloyd, set the gold standard for sitcoms in the late 1960s, maintained it over 20 years and came up, time after time, with new ideas to make audiences roar.

It's quite an achievement. Permission to weep, sir.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus

Day In a Page

IoS Appeal: The civil war has ended – now the war on disease has begun

IoS Christmas Appeal

The civil war has ended – now the war on disease has begun
Ian Blair: Assisted dying needs a change of heart

Ian Blair: Assisted dying needs a change of heart

The law is unclear and needs changing when those wanting to end the suffering of their loved ones still fear being sent to prison
Alan Titchmarsh: From botany to Borodin – a major shift in culture

Alan Titchmarsh interview

From botany to Borodin – a major shift in culture
Roman Krznaric: Are you hooked on gadgets? Then it's time you went on a digital diet

Roman Krznaric

Are you hooked on gadgets? Then it's time you went on a digital diet
Fashion at the museum brings in the crowds

Fashion at the museum brings in the crowds

Prepare to queue for glimpses of finery created by top designers
Olympics 1948 & 2012: Two Games - 64 years, and worlds apart

Olympics 1948 & 2012

Two Games - 64 years, and worlds apart
How much is a British gold medal worth? £2m

How much is a British gold medal worth? £2m

Home athletes on the podium will earn riches beyond their wildest dreams from sponsors, TV shows and a host of other deals
What the Dickens? Try our literary quiz

What the Dickens? Try our literary quiz

Know your Nickleby from your Nell? How many questions can you answer about one of English literature's greatest figures?
Shadduppa ya stereotype! Italian-Americans fight back

Shadduppa ya stereotype!

Italian-Americans fight back
The future starts here: Our experts predict the trends of 2012

The trends of 2012

What will the next 12 months bring? Our experts predict…
Shape up: 10 ways to get fit without spending hours on a treadmill

Shape up: 10 ways to get fit

Can't face the gym? You don’t have to with the new ilk of fitness regime, from rush hockey to mammoth-chasing
See the light: Bill Granger's tasty recipes for a healthy start to the year

See the light: Bill Granger's healthy meals

After the Christmas excesses, the chef suggests a few light meals
Dennis Tueart: A prime mover in tale of two Cities

Dennis Tueart: A prime mover in tale of two Cities

As Henry returns from New York, the man who replaced Pele at the Cosmos tells how he came back to set up Manchester's new empire
Ian Holloway: Why I was wrong to hang on to Adam... and other January horror stories

Ian Holloway

Why I was wrong to hang on to Adam... and other January horror stories
The Last Word: FA await their dates with calendar guys

FA await their dates with calendar guys

Upcoming court cases for key figures Terry and Redknapp will shape England's future in 2012