Donald MacInnes: Can you really put a price on magic? Even second-rate magic?

 

Why are we at all surprised when, at this time of year, we go through money like a canoe through water? Since when was Christmas anything at all to do with good financial sense?

Mary and Joseph were penniless, for heaven's sake. Their lodgings for the big night – a stable – was not some straw-strewn, barn-themed Bethlehem Travelodge. No, they had to bed down in an actual stable. And because it was essentially, you know, a donkey's toilet, you could have hung curtains on the smell. But it was all they could afford and they were darn grateful to have somewhere to lay their halos.

Now, I'm not here to cast scorn on those who equate Christmas with cash money, be it squandered or spent frugally. There is a lot of green being thrown around just now, so go ahead – exchange it for whatever you fancy. Just don't expect to get decent value for your festive doubloons.

I thus found my eyeballs rolling violently, as I read about the dissatisfaction shown by many woolly-jumpered families when they visited the much-derided winter wonderland theme area which was creatively overlorded by that most ludicrous of popinjays, His Velvetness Laurence Llewelyn-Bowen. The Magical Journey, as the attraction was known, began near Sutton Coldfield (as all magical journeys surely must).

I'm not entirely sure why some people are complaining that the journey they undertook wasn't magical enough. But they are. One of the disgruntled attendees, Ms Michelle Guarini, moaned: "The Christmas market was about six shacks and there were some elves who didn't seem to know what they were doing."

Look, I'm no apologist for Larry Loo-Bowl, but come on, Michelle! Yes, you may have been charged a tenner to get in, but you saw elves! How can you be so blasé about catching sight of magical creatures that, just a few days ago, would have been dismissed as mere constructs of a storyteller's imagination? But your own eyes have confirmed that they exist! Does it really matter that they "didn't seem to know what they were doing"? Of course they didn't! They were out of their element! Probably still sleigh-lagged. You think wearing bells on your toes and a big pointy hat is fun?

Anyway, I have had a far worse festive experience. Only a few days ago I was pinballing through the television channels and was unfortunate enough to catch sight of the Sainsbury's "Christmas in the Trenches" advert. How the retail group's marketing team and its board of directors must have high-fived each other when they came up with the idea of slapping their logo on to the First World War; what business nous! It needs a special kind of genius to take the public's enduring and very palpable sympathy for those lads in the trenches and make some real wedge out of it. Well, guess what, Sainsbury's? You were wrong and your advert is monstrous. Go away and have a think.

Twitter.com/DonaldAMacInnes

Independent Partners; Do you need financial advice on your investments, pension or insurance? Book a free consultation with an independent Financial Adviser at VouchedFor.co.uk

Finacial products from our partners
Property search
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

ES Rentals

    iJobs Job Widget
    iJobs Money & Business

    Recruitment Genius: Claims Handler

    £18000 - £25000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This Claims Management company ...

    Recruitment Genius: Admin Assistant

    £12000 - £15000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: An expanding Insurance Brokerag...

    Ashdown Group: Learning and Development Programme Manager - Team Lead

    £45000 - £50000 per annum + benefits: Ashdown Group: A highly successful, inte...

    Ashdown Group: Learning and Development Programme Manager

    £35000 - £38000 per annum + benefits : Ashdown Group: A highly successful, int...

    Day In a Page

    Genetically engineering mosquitoes to end malaria could have unintended consequences

    An end to malaria

    But could genetically engineering mosquitoes have other, unintended consequences?
    Life under Isis: As long as its enemies remain divided, the militants will not be defeated

    As long as its enemies remain divided, Isis will not be defeated

    The jihadis can conscript, train and arm thousands of fighters, but their resilience is based on their opponents waging separate wars, says Patrick Cockburn
    Marion Maréchal-Le Pen: The poster-girl of the French far-right is more extreme than her aunt and bigger box office than her grandfather

    Poster-girl of the French far-right

    As France goes to the polls, Marine Le Pen's party, the Front National, looks set to do well. And key to that rise has been Le Pen's fiery niece Marion, the FN's rising star
    Tunisia shooting: When Isis attacks a museum to destroy the ‘culture of its disbelievers’, what treasure of the Western world is now safe?

    Robert Fisk on Tunisia attack

    When Isis targets a museum to destroy the ‘culture of its disbelievers’, what treasure of the Western world is now safe?
    UN's International Day Of Happiness: How can we define or achieve it ... and who's profiting?

    How can we define or achieve happiness?

    It's the UN's International Day Of Happiness tomorrow, but Rhodri Marsden finds the happiness business makes him, well, a bit unhappy
    Goodbye, bell bottoms: the Royal Navy has got a 'cool' new uniform for the first time in 70 years

    Royal Navy gets a 'cool' new uniform

    The Independent's fashion editor Alexander Fury reveals why the nautical new look is making waves
    The Carolina Butcher: Paleontologists find ancient crocodiles which walked on hind legs

    Paleontologists find ancient crocodiles which walked on hind legs

    9ft animal roamed South Carolina 220m years ago
    Meat Free Week: Star chefs from Raymond Blanc to Thomasina Miers share their veggie tips

    Meat Free Week: Star chefs share their tips

    Meat Free Week is part of a global campaign to steer us to a more planet-friendly diet
    11 best men's moisturisers

    11 best men's moisturisers

    Keep your face feeling smooth and hydrated with a hardworking cream. We give our verdict on the pick of the potions
    Paul Scholes column: Outplayed, outfought and out-thought: once again, our English clubs have been miles off the pace in Europe

    Paul Scholes column

    Outplayed, outfought and out-thought: once again, our English clubs have been miles off the pace in Europe
    Frank Warren: Derry Mathews must teach emigre Richar Abril a few home truths

    Mathews must teach emigre Abril a few home truths

    Home advantage can be crucial, the difference between victory and defeat, says Frank Warren
    Budget 2015: What George Osborne said... and what he really meant

    The Budget 2015

    What George Osborne said... and what he really meant
    Life under Isis: Sunnis face an even bleaker future in Iraq if the militants' reign of terror is finally defeated

    Life under Isis

    Sunnis face an even bleaker future in Iraq if militants' reign of terror is finally defeated, says Patrick Cockburn
    New genetic map of Britain shows successive waves of immigration going back 10,000 years

    A nation of immigrants

    How a remarkable new genetic map tells a story of Britons' survival
    The weird world of Boris Berezovsky: Alexander Litvinenko's inquest has provided an intriguing insight into the dead tycoon

    The weird world of Boris Berezovsky

    Alexander Litvinenko's inquest has provided an intriguing insight into the dead tycoon