Q & A: Is this bad news for ordinary people? Or absolutely disastrous news?
Saturday 24 September 2011
From the blogs
Apple invitation all but confirms next week’s iPhone 5 announcement
Apple have sent out invitations to it’s much anticipated iPhone 5 announcement next week, but with s...
Your generation coped without degrees, I’m not sure all of ours can
This sort of rhetoric parroted every year by a generation laughably removed from the youth employmen...
Arrested development: Economic circumstance is forcing grown adults to live like juveniles
The cost of living, a challenging job market, difficulties in obtaining credit and historically high...
Q. So I see the stock market rose yesterday. Are the problems over?
AIf only. The stock market is a poor guide to the health of the world economy at the best of times. Lots of other markets were still in freefall – many commodities plunged and credit market indicators are flashing an ever more scarlet shade. In the Prime Minister's words, we are still "staring down the barrel".
Q. What's the biggest problem at the moment?
A. The marked slowdown in the pace of the global recovery. It's the same across almost all industrialised nations, including the US, the world's largest economy, where unemployment remains close to 10 per cent and the disastrous housing market is damaging people's confidence.
Governments are also under huge pressure to reduce their debts, which limits what they can do to promote growth. The quandary facing Britain's government – how much can we cut by without tipping the economy back into recession – is familiar the world over.
Q. And where do the banks fit into all this?
A. Their primary worry is the eurozone sovereign debt crisis. Greece owes so much money, the markets don't believe it can pay it all back, however much the eurozone protests. Much of the money is owed to European banks, which would be very seriously damaged if Greece were to default.
Q. How will events play out if it does reach crisis point?
A. Remember what happened last time banks started failing in 2008? The entire financial system can go into lockdown very quickly – no one knows how badly anyone else is damaged, so everyone pulls in their horns. Banks stop lending to each other, which threatens more institutions; eventually they may find it difficult to fund their day-to-day operations – like filling up cash machines. Banks may also stop lending – to businesses and households. That's disastrous, as the economy can't grow without credit to oil the wheels. Many countries plunge back into recession.
Q. Is all this financial trouble coming from Greece?
A. Greece doesn't exist in a vacuum. Many say countries with much larger economies – Spain and Italy, for instance – are in danger of going the same way. A Greek default would add to the chances of those fears being realised, since it would do such serious damage to their banks and economies. Then we might have more sovereign debt defaults and yet another round of bank failures. A vicious circle.
Q. If Greece defaults, would happen then?
A. We'd have another global recession, probably even deeper than in 2009, when the world economy shrank by 0.7 per cent (the figure for the UK was 4.9 per cent). Governments have almost run out of ammunition to throw at the slowdown, so pulling the world out of the spiral would be even harder than last time.
Q. What can we do to prevent all this?
A. The short answer is a great deal more than we are doing today. Yesterday's G20 communique was typical of policymakers' response so far: strong on words, short on detailed action.
Q. So what can be done to fix the economy in the long term?
A. The first thing to deal with is Europe. Greece is going to default on its debts within days unless it gets the next slice of promised bail-out money. Eurozone leaders will, sooner or later, have to accept the markets' view that a default of some sort is certain. Such an event can be dealt with, if it is anticipated.
The size of the European Financial Stability Facility, the European bail-out fund, needs to substantially increased, and the launch of the European Stability Mechanism, due to replace it in 2013, brought forward. The less weaker banks in Europe will have to be strengthened. We may have to pool the eurozone's debts which, in totality, are manageable. There will also have to be closer fiscal integration, so that individual members of the euro can never again get themselves into this sort of trouble. That may well mean some sort of eurozone treasury.
Q. So why doesn't the eurozone just get on with it?
A. Because these are difficult ideas to sell to taxpayers. In Germany, people want to know why they should have to pay for the profligacy of others. Looking ahead, fiscal integration is undemocratic. It means voters in any one member state have much less control over economic policy. In the eurozone, where the lack of political accountability is already an issue for many, that's tough to take.
Q. Would solving the eurozone crisis at least secure the global recovery?
A. Not necessarily, though not solving it would certainly mean recession. We are also going to have to address other matters. It's difficult to see how the US economy will leap forward until the mess in the housing market has been resolved. That may have to mean writing off some of the debts outstanding – and working to ensure America's banks can take that pain. We probably are going to see more quantitative easing in Britain, and similar policies elsewhere (like the $400bn bond purchases the US Federal Reserve announced this week). But cutting the cost of borrowing and ensuring more credit is available is no use unless individuals and businesses are confident enough to take advantage. Recovery is going to take a while.
Q. How can we prevent this happening again in a few years' time?
A. We're back to the tricky business of politics. The global economy is horribly unbalanced, with the world's exporters selling the rest of us their wares but also lending us the money to buy them. The imbalances have been exaggerated by some deliberate policy interventions – like China's determination to keep its currency hugely undervalued, which has the effect of making its goods much cheaper they should be. Over-borrowed countries need to reduce their debts, exporting nations need to find more domestic sources of demand and the world needs to agree on how to make the transition to a system with fewer trade barriers and currency controls.
Q. So what's the short answer then? should we not hold our breath?
A. Let's just say that when Christine Lagarde, the IMF managing director, warned yesterday that this weekend's meetings probably wouldn't be able find solutions but would try to agree on a "common diagnosis", she was being optimistic.
-
Analysts' thumbs down for smartphones sees shares tumble at Nokia
-
Muslim woman's body found in hospital morgue covered with bacon
-
Exclusive: Ed Balls - I'm planning a proper wealth tax
-
The 10 Best back-to-school gadgets
-
Four killed in attack on British car in French Alps beauty spot
-
Canada stunned by fatal shooting at victory rally for Quebec separatists
-
Beware of the cat: Britain's hidden toxoplasma problem
-
The islands that divide superpowers
-
Home extensions boom planned - but cracks grow in Coalition foundations
-
News in pictures
- 1 Never mind the fat. It's being fit that matters
- 2 Jermain Defoe reveals the 'madness' at Tottenham during transfer window
- 3 The 10 Best water bottles
- 4 Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini, his final interview, and a damning critique that has rocked the Catholic Church
- 5 James Lawton: Liverpool add sorry postscript to the tale of Michael Owen's under-appreciated gifts
- 6 The 10 Best back-to-school gadgets
- 7 Beware of the cat: Britain's hidden toxoplasma problem
- 8 How leaping into bed harms relationships
- 9 Manchester United to argue case for tighter controls on spending in the Premier League
Experience the Heineken Hub
Get free wi-fi and exclusive i content while you enjoy a tasty pint of Heineken at participating pubs.
A legacy we can be proud of
The most lasting effect London 2012 will have is to motivate children all over the UK to get interested in science, technology, engineering and maths
Want to make cash from your spare room?
Let out your house, flat or spare room with Airbnb and make some money.
Now showing at the O2
Check out the cool stuff happening under our tent: the hottest gigs, comedy, sport, films, clubs, bars, restaurants and much more.
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Comments