Letter: Things that only a wife can say

Share
Related Topics
Sir: Bruce Anderson ('President Billary and the liberal dilemma', 25 January) mars a serious discussion of the ideas of the Democratic Party by personal criticism of President Clinton for willingness to listen to the advice of his wife. This is a line of argument which goes back to Adam in the Garden of Eden, and the Almighty was right to find it distinctively unimpressive.

There is a different tradition which argues that a ruler's greatest need is for someone who will give frank advice not fuelled by the promotion-driven urge to tell him what he wants to hear. The value of such advice need not depend on its correctness. It depends on the need for intellectual challenge. Perhaps only a spouse can muster the combination of devotion and disrespect which such advice demands.

It is also instructive to look at the absence of similar criticism of male spouses. One of the few refreshing features of the Thatcher years was the absence of any voyeuristic interest in searching for the hidden hand of Sir Denis. What was sauce for the gander should be sauce for the goose.

Yours sincerely,

RUSSELL

House of Lords

London, SW1

25 January

React Now

Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
SPONSORED FEATURES
iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Recruitment Genius: Call Centre Sales Operations Manager

£40000 - £75000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This innovative online car purc...

Recruitment Genius: HR and Administrative Assistant

£23000 - £26000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This Data Management organisati...

Recruitment Genius: Part-Time Video Inventory and Inspection Clerk

£14500 per annum: Recruitment Genius: A part-time video Inventory and Inspecti...

Recruitment Genius: Designer - Web & Motion / Video

£15000 - £20000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This is an opportunity to join ...

Day In a Page

Read Next
Benjamin Netanyahu has compared the Iran deal to the appeasement of the Nazis in 1938  

Iran nuclear deal: Benjamin Netanyahu should make the most of this 'stunning mistake'

Donald Macintyre
An Italian policeman stands guard as migrants eat while waiting at the port of Lampedusa to board a ferry bound for Porto Empedocle in Sicily. Authorities on the Italian island of Lampedusa struggled to cope with a huge influx of newly-arrived migrants as aid organisations warned the Libya crisis means thousands more could be on their way  

60 million people are now displaced, fleeing from beheadings, torture and rape — migrant policies are failing

Arjan Hehenkamp
On the front line of the war against Isis, joint action by US and Iran has never felt closer

On the front line of the war against Isis, joint action by US and Iran has never felt closer

Shia militiamen believe the nuclear deal will herald more American help in battle to liberate Iraq. Patrick Cockburn reports from Najaf
Riba Stirling Prize 2015: Shortlisted entries for British architecture's 'Oscar' are bling-free and created with people in mind

Designs for living: Riba Stirling Prize 2015

The shortlisted entries for British architecture's 'Oscar' are bling-free and created with people in mind
Google Effect: Is technology making us stupid?

Is technology making us stupid?

Can't remember phone numbers or birthdays? You may be suffering from the 'Google Effect'
Why writers treasure islands: Isolated, remote, defended - they're great places for story-telling

Why writers treasure islands

Isolated, remote, defended - they're great places for story-telling
Steve Wintercroft's fox masks stole the show at this week's anti-hunting demonstrations

The man behind the fox masks

Steve Wintercroft's masks stole the show at this week's anti-foxhunting demonstrations
Tompkins Table 2015: Magdalene College has seen a remarkable improvement

Tompkins Table 2015

Magdalene College has seen a remarkable improvement
11 best sunglasses for kids

Eye protection: 11 best sunglasses for kids

You assiduously slather them in sun cream and cram hats on their heads, but do you think about their eyes? We've got it sorted
Ashes 2015: Australia's captain Michael Clarke is already wearing look of a haunted man

Clarke is already wearing look of a haunted man

He wears a pain behind his eyes even before this Ashes road starts rolling out before him, says Ian Herbert
The Open 2015: Special Jordan Spieth relishing chance to rewrite history at the home of golf

The Open

Special Spieth relishing chance to rewrite history at the home of golf
The Open 2015: Rickie Fowler and Sergio Garcia ready to step out of Rory McIlroy's shadow

Fowler and Garcia ready to step out of Rory's shadow

Duo who chased McIlroy in vain at last year’s Open are confident of taking their chance this time and getting hold of that Claret Jug
Iran nuclear deal: However the great and good represent it, America has now taken the Shia side in the Middle East's sectarian war

America takes Iran's side (to Israeli and Saudi fury)

In the subtext to a historic deal many thought impossible lies a remarkable Shia triumph in a decades-long sectarian conflict. Has the region’s balance of power changed forever, asks Robert Fisk
The most efficient government in the world has been announced... and it's Qatar

The most efficient government in the world has been announced...

League table compiled by the World Economic Forum has surprising entry in top spot
Nairobi Westgate attack: Shopping mall re-opens two years after terror siege where al-Shabaab killed 67 people

Nairobi Westgate attack, two years on

Shopping mall where al-Shabaab killed 67 people re-opens - but so much remains unknown about the atrocity
How heavy is a kilogram? International scientific effort to redefine the kilo makes breakthrough

How heavy is a kilogram?

International scientific effort to redefine the kilo makes breakthrough
Go Set A Watchman: 'Finch fries' all round as Harper Lee’s home town celebrates book launch

'Finch fries' all round as Harper Lee's home town celebrates book launch

Street parties held ahead of the long-awaited release of To Kill a Mockingbird sequel