MAHLER: Symphonies Nos 3, 6 and 10 (first and third movements only)
Hilde Rossl-Majdan (contralto), Vienna Boys' Choir,
Vienna State Opera Chorus, Vienna SO/ Charles Adler
(recorded: 1951-2)
Conifer 75605 51279 2 (three CDs)
Rough-cut slices of Mahlerian history, gritty, uncompromising and - in some respects at least - more gripping, more profoundly authentic, than many of the Mahler performances you'll hear nowadays. London-born Charles Adler assisted Mahler at the premiere of his Eighth Symphony in Munich; he also conducted for Diaghilev, organised his own publishing house (rolling Ives and Cowell off the presses when few others dared), landed penniless in New York and co-founded the record company, the Society of Participating Artists (or SPA), that made these premiere recordings.
Vintage Brits may remember them from ancient "cheap LP" reissues, though only No 3 has made it onto CD before. Some will scoff at the scuffs, the approximate playing, the occasional lapses in ensemble and the variable - though by no means bad - sound quality. And yet I challenge any reader to locate a more humbling performance of the Third Symphony's primeval first movement, dark, brooding music, formidably powerful and keenly responsive to Adler's long-breathed phrasing. The Sixth is grim and unhurried, with the Neanderthal Scherzo and idyllic Andante (an eloquent reading) played in reverse order - an option that Mahler himself sometimes favoured. Again, there's the odd executive crack or splinter, but far better rugged Mahler played with conviction than hammy exaggeration or brainless emotional overkill. A real tonic, much enhanced by exemplary, fact-filled documentation.
Rob Cowan
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
Join our new commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies