The House With A Clock In Its Walls review: A beguiling piece of gothic whimsy

It takes a while for the film to build momentum but once the characters are introduced and the plot lines are drawn, the pace soon picks u

Geoffrey Macnab

Wednesday 19 September 2018 14:58

✕

The House With a Clock In Its Walls

Dir: Eli Roth; Starring: Cate Blanchett, Jack Black, Owen Vaccaro, Kyle MacLachlan. Cert 12A, 105 mins.

When you see Eli Roth’s name on the credits, you can usually reasonably expect some cannibalism and skin flaying at the very least. However, the director best-known as one of the high priests of ‘torture porn’ is showing an altogether gentler side in The House With A Clock In Its Walls.

This is a beguiling piece of gothic whimsy more in the spirit of Steven Spielberg (whose Amblin Entertainment helped produce it) than of the usual Roth splatterfests like Cabin Fever and Hostel.

Nothing much here is especially original. The 1950s settings and the storyline, about an 11-year-old kid dealing with bereavement by dabbling in magic, are strangely (and reassuringly) familiar. This is a film that you feel you’ve seen before, even as you watch it for the first time.

The doe-eyed waif Lewis (Owen Vaccaro) could have stepped out of the pages of Charles Dickens... or of Lemony Snicket. Jack Black’s character, the loud and flamboyant uncle who likes to wear kimonos and pull multiple handkerchiefs from his sleeve, is likewise an archetype similar to many other bungling uncles.

He’s a “warlock” who has all the majesty of a cheap conjuror at a children’s party. Cate Blanchett is arguably a little too glamorous to play the spinster-like witch, Florence Zimmerman, who has simmering grief of her own – but she is utterly commanding as always.

The film flits between Lewis’ new life with uncle Jonathan in an Addams family-style haunted house and his misadventures at his new school, where he is picked on because he wears goggles and bow ties and is no good at sport.

Uncle Jonathan’s approach to parenting is unconventional. In his house, there is no bed time, no bath time and no meal time. Lewis can eat chocolate chip cookies whenever he likes. The one rule is that he can’t open the cabinet in the hall.

To do so might risk waking up the dead and bringing back to life Jonathan’s estranged wizard friend, Isaac Izard (Kyle MacLachlan beneath many layers of make-up), who is hatching fiendish plans to push the world back in time and toward oblivion.

Access unlimited streaming of movies and TV shows with Amazon Prime Video Sign up now for a 30-day free trial

The best films of 2018 (so far)

Show all 17

1/17The best films of 2018 (so far)

From its slow-burning beginning, The Guardians develops into an epic melodrama. It’s a wartime story in which, for a change, the men are relegated to supporting roles. It follows in a tradition of French rural family sagas like Jean De Florette or Manon Des Sources. The landscapes and the changing seasons play as much of a part in the story as the main characters.

Dark River offers little such consolation. It has some lyrical and delicate moments but the mood is generally overwhelmingly bleak and lugubrious. Incest and abuse don’t leave much space for any comic interludes. This is a powerful film with a grinding intensity about it. Light relief it isn’t but Dark River still has quite an impact.

Alamy

Late on in Argentinean director Lucrecia Martel’s startling, highly original new feature, Zama, a character who has just had both his arms cut off, is advised to “shove your stumps in the sand … if you don’t bleed out, you’ll survive.” It’s a grisly, darkly humorous moment in a film that continually surprises us with both its brutality and its lyricism.

The Match Factory

The most dispiriting aspect of this otherwise enrapturing Oscar-nominated animated feature is that its storyline still seems so current. The film depicts an Afghan society in which women don’t have a face. It is set during the Taliban rule, which lasted from the mid-1990s until late 2001, but this doesn’t feel like a period piece. Seventeen years after the Taliban were ousted from power in Afghanistan following the US invasion, the plight of women in the country appears hardly to have improved.

GKIDS

Spike Lee’s work sometimes risks sensory overload. He fires off so many different ideas and storytelling styles that audiences can become bamboozled by his scattergun approach. BlacKkKlansman is one of his very best films because the digressions are as entertaining as ever but don’t get in the way of the main story.

AP

Much of the pleasure in Aardman films has always lain in their gently ironic, Alan Bennett-like humour. They take very exotic characters and subject matter but then deal with them in a matter-of-fact fashion. They make a virtue out of their own relative modesty. Early Man isn’t the flashiest animated feature that you’ll see this year but it is certainly the most likeable.

Like all of Wes Anderson’s work, Isle Of Dogs is very stylised, very offbeat and characterised by its extremely dry and often ironic humour. This Japanese-set stop-motion fable is also gorgeous to look at – packed full of intricate visual detail. It deals with some weighty themes (ethnic cleansing, fascism and corruption) but does so in an idiosyncratic fashion.

Writer-director Martin McDonagh has a host of award-winning plays behind him but his movies haven’t always lived up to his stage work. This one certainly does. It shares some of the dark and nihilistic humour found in McDonagh’s previous film, Seven Psychopaths.

In an era of wearisome poltergeist movies, haunted house stories and torture porn, A Quiet Place is a refreshingly pared-down and very original affair. Director John Krasinski relies on editing, sound effects and off-screen action to crank up the tension. We do see the creatures from time to time, sometimes even in extreme closeup. They are very grotesque, bigger versions of the polyp-like succubus which exploded out of John Hurt’s stomach in Alien. However, the most terrifying moments here come when the humans are waiting for them to appear, desperately hoping that they won’t.

Paramount Pictures

Lady Bird is one of the best American coming-of-age films since Barry Levinson’s Diner. Written and directed by Greta Gerwig, it offers an utterly winning mix of humour, poignancy and sharp-eyed social observation. Gerwig approaches her subject matter with the same tenderness and affectionate irony with which the adolescent Lady Bird regards Sacramento. Gerwig also shows Lady Bird’s heroism as the young heroine strives against the odds to become the very best version of herself she can be.

A24

If Phantom Thread is indeed Daniel Day-Lewis’s final film as an actor, he is going out on a wondrously bizarre note. This must be the oddest film in his career, one in which he gives a typically commanding but very idiosyncratic performance. Almost everything here is jarring – but generally in a very positive way.

It is not so long ago that Paul Schrader seemed to be giving up on cinema. The American writer-director (whose credits include Taxi Driver, American Gigolo and Affliction) had taken to making movies like the sour Hollywood satire The Canyons with Lindsay Lohan and the cartoonishly violent Dog Eat Dog, shot cheaply, aimed at a VOD audience. The former had a montage of closed-down movie theatres. In interviews, Schrader struck a gloomy note about the future of the industry. This is why First Reformed is so refreshing. This is not just Schrader’s best film in a very long while. It is also a re-affirmation of the director’s belief in the medium.

Rex

Oscar Wilde goes to ruin in Rupert Everett’s debut feature as director. Everett also wrote and stars in the film, giving a grandstanding performance as the Irish writer at the end of his life, after his release from prison, where he has been doing hard labour for “gross indecency”. This is a moving and surprising biopic that squeezes out every last drop of pathos from its subject matter.

BBC Films

Black Panther is not only one of the most entertaining recent superhero films but has an intelligence and a political dimension that such inchoate offerings as Suicide Squad and Justice League completely lacked. It is an action movie which touches on Pan-Africanism and which owes as much to Malcolm X as it does to Batman or Captain America.

Marvel Studios/Disney

Sicilian Ghost Story is a genre-bending affair that combines elements of teen romance, gothic psycho-drama and political thriller. It is loosely based on a true story of a boy called Giuseppe Di Matteo whose father, an ex-member of the Sicilian Mafia, turned “grass” against his erstwhile associates. The Mafia responded by kidnapping Giuseppe and keeping him in captivity for nearly 800 days.

Altitude

First Man is all about understated heroism. It’s affecting precisely because Armstrong (played with quiet intensity by Ryan Gosling) doesn’t feel the continual need to boast about his mission. The film is a tearjerker but a very subtle one.

AP

Dogman is one of the best Italian films of recent times, a modern day neo realist fable that bears comparison with the great work of Fellini, Rossellini, De Sica et al. Its main character, the dog groomer Marcello (Marcello Fonte), is a wonderful creation: loveable, vulnerable, seedy and comic all at the same time.

Curzon Artificial Eye

The House with a Clock in Its Walls is adapted from a mystery novel for children by American author, John Bellairs. Thankfully, Roth never allows it to become too soft-centred. He may not spill as much blood as in most of his previous movies but he makes ingenious use of squelchy pumpkin pulp.

Roth also fills the film with sly homages to old Hollywood horror movies and silent films as well as to 50s sci-fi series. The house itself, with its moving furniture and its bric a brac and mannequins which have a life of its own, is one of the major characters in the story.

It takes a while for the film to build momentum but once the characters are introduced and the plot lines are drawn, the pace soon picks up. Jack Black and Cate Blanchett have an easy comic rapport, affectionately bad mouthing one another and trying to steal scenes from under each other’s noses. Roth keeps matters light but still succeeds in giving the audience a few jolts.

The House with A Clock in its Walls is released in UK cinemas on 21 September

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies